Book Review of CARDINAL MAHONY - Pub 2007 by Robert Blair Kaiser

This novel begins with the transformation of afullness of time you sent your only Son to be our
fictionalized American cardinal after he realizes he hasSavior. He was conceived through the power of the
conducted himself more like the chief executive officerHoly Spirit, and born of the Virgin Mary, a man like us in
of a big business rather than as a pastor whose lifeall things but sin. To the poor he proclaimed the good
reflects Christ's teachings to feed the hungry, shelternews of salvation, to prisoners, freedom, and to those
the homeless, care for the sick, etc. At the outset,in sorrow, joy. In fulfillment of your will he gave himself
many readers might feel they could predict theup to death; but by rising from the dead, he destroyed
outcome before finishing the novel: the prelate woulddeath and restored life. And that we might live no
be treated like a pariah by his fellow bishops andlonger for ourselves but for him, he sent the Holy Spirit
quietly removed from his post, with a successorfrom you, Father, as his first gift to those who believe,
appointed who understands the foremost rule ofto complete his work on earth and bring us the fullness
today's Catholic bishops is to fall in lockstep behind theof grace."
pope. But the novel has unexpected twists and turns.Why NOT let the laity -- the congregation -- say these
Approximately one-quarter through the book, thebeautiful words out loud during mass? For too long, the
author, a former journalist who covered the Vatican IIconservatives running the Church have tried to
council for TIME magazine, introduced a number ofmaintain the pre-Vatican II notion that the clergy
thought-provoking ideas to enhance the laity'sdispense God's graces and the laity's job is to seek
participation in all aspects of the church. As the muchpassively these ministerial graces from clergy - in a
beloved good Pope John XXIII once said, "The Catholicprocess ultimately controlled by the Vatican. Yet, in
Church is its people," as distinguished from its hierarchy.1965 towards the end of the Vatican II council, Pope
In the novel, the priest shortage leads one church inPaul VI noted that the passive nature of the laity had
California administered by a nun to have communionchanged. Outside of mass, Vatican II sought to codify
services in lieu of a mass. But the nun in this storyand recognize the laity had spiritual gifts equal to (if not
does something relatively unique: she invites the smallgreater than) the spiritual gifts of the clergy.
congregation to join her in saying the eucharistic prayerHow welcome indeed then are the scenes depicted in
in unison out loud.CARDINAL MAHONY, in which the Church in
When word of these communion services reachesCalifornia, and eventually across the country, rallies
the local bishop and eventually the Vatican, all thearound the renegade nun, forces the conservative
conservatives are horrified that this upstart nun ishierarchy to back down, and demands a greater say
democratizing the mass and letting all the congregationin the administration of the church and the
join in feeling they play a role in consecrating breadaccountability of its bishops. The novel explains the
and wine into the body and blood of Christ. But aconcept of an autochthonous church - which is 100%
participant at the communion service describes it thisCatholic and loyal to the pope, yet retains for itself
way. "First thing I'd say, we don't call them Masses.certain decision-making power. As Kaiser explains,
Second thing, these are the most devout, solemnautochthony does not mean autonomy; it means
liturgies I have ever seen. When we say the words (of"home grown."
the eucharistic prayer), we say them in the kind ofAccording to Kaiser, as of 2007, the Vatican
wonder-filled tones we use when we're reading ourrecognizes twenty-one autochthonous churches inside
nieces and nephews their bedtime stories."the Catholic Church. These churches include the
Nevertheless the Vatican and America's conservativeMelkites in Lebanon, the Maronites, and an Eastern
bishops get all in a tizzy over the very thought ofEuropean branch that has maintained married Catholic
people saying the same words used by the priest atpriests from its first existence. In fact, the Roman
mass.Catholic Church in Africa and Latin America today
The typical Catholic mass in America involves a priestalready has "home grown" elements in the prevalence
giving a too-long homily and then making up for lostof priests with unofficial companions. "It's an open
time by racing through the shortest eucharistic prayersecret that many Roman Catholic priests -- especially
for consecration. Because of this time constraint, thein African and Latin American nations -- have taken
fourth eucharistic prayer, which is the longest of thecommon-law wives," wrote Don Lattin in a nationally
four prayers available for consecration, is seldom used.circulated religious article for the San Francisco
Yet Eucharistic Prayer IV contains the most beautifulChronicle in 1994.
words of all: "Father, you so loved the world that in the